Skip to main content

Good Notes

Voices of U of U Health

Subscribe Now

Clinical Ethics: When Medical Decisions Have No Clear Answer

By Eleanor Gilmore Szott, PhD

Sometimes, medicine offers several possible paths, but no clear answer about which one to take. Medical facts can inform the decision, but they cannot always determine what is right for an individual patient. That requires understanding what matters most to the person receiving care. This is where clinical ethics comes into play.

As a clinical ethicist, I help patients, families, and care teams work through difficult ethical situations and find a way forward. Sometimes that means uncovering assumptions or helping people see the choices more clearly. My role is never to make the decisions for them. It is to help them arrive at a path that is ethically sound and reflects the patient’s wishes. 

Health care provider in a white coat gently holds a patient's hands during a consultation.

Starting With the Patient’s Story

Clinical ethics consultation often begins when the way forward is unclear. A patient may be unable to make a decision, or the people involved may disagree about what should happen next. Sometimes, the tension stems from communication. Other times, people see the situation differently because of the values they bring to it.

My first step is to understand the situation from multiple perspectives. I learn about the patient’s medical condition from the care team and meet with the patient and family whenever possible. Even when a patient cannot speak for themselves, their values and experiences remain central to the conversation.

We all make value judgments, often without recognizing the values behind them. Those values may be shaped by family, culture, faith, life experience, or professional responsibilities. One person may place great importance on independence, while another may prioritize comfort or living as long as possible.

When patients cannot tell us what matters to them, we turn to the people who know them best. I ask loved ones to tell me about the person and the life they’ve been living. What matters to them? What brings them joy? What are they proud of or afraid of? How did they make important decisions in the past?

The formal term for this process is values elucidation. Families often piece together a patient’s wishes from snippets of conversations and experiences gathered over a lifetime. I help them consider what those pieces tell us about the choices the patient would make for themselves.

When Treatment Changes Daily Life

My research on informed consent distinguishes between factual and personalized understanding. Factual understanding means being able to describe, in your own words, what a procedure involves and what to expect from it.

Personalized understanding goes further. It means recognizing how those medical facts might affect your own life. That requires a kind of imaginative forecasting. If a medication may cause dizziness and you ride your bike to work, for example, an important part of your daily routine may have to change. Truly understanding a medical decision means being able to anticipate those effects and consider them in light of what matters most to you.

Consider a patient deciding whether to receive a left ventricular assist device, or LVAD, which helps the heart pump blood. The device may allow someone to leave the hospital and spend more time with family. But it can also change what everyday life looks like.

For someone living on a family farm who values independence, driving around the property might be central to the life they want to maintain. An LVAD could lead to driving restrictions or future hospital stays. Those possibilities take on greater meaning when considered alongside the patient’s priorities. 

A treatment might make sense medically. Whether it represents good care also depends on what the person values and what trade-offs they’re willing to accept. That’s why asking, “What does a good day look like?” can be an important clinical question. It moves the conversation beyond what a treatment can do and toward what that treatment means for the life a patient hopes to preserve.

How the Humanities Shape Care

The humanities help us understand other people’s experiences. Stories and art can let us see the world from another person’s perspective. My background is in philosophy, with a focus on ethics, bioethics, and informed consent. That is my slice of the humanities pie.

Philosophical training has taught me to examine the assumptions behind our ideas about what is good and apply ethical principles to questions in health care. That matters because, while we all want to provide good medicine, “good” does not necessarily mean the same thing for every patient. A treatment may be medically appropriate for a diagnosis without being right for a particular person. Clinical ethics helps us understand that distinction by considering the patient’s perspective alongside the medical facts.

This emphasis on helping people understand their choices, rather than making decisions for them, makes University of Utah Health’s Center for Health Ethics, Arts, and Humanities a natural home for clinical ethics. We create space for patients, families, and clinicians to think through difficult decisions with greater clarity while centering the patient.

Clinical ethics also works at a systems level. The center connects clinical ethics with humanities disciplines, such as philosophy and law, that broaden how we think about complex questions in health care. This humanities-informed approach can help clinicians recognize ethical concerns earlier. It can also help them determine what they can address themselves and when additional support may be needed.

Sharing the Weight of Difficult Decisions

Sometimes, a clinical ethics consultation cannot resolve the moral challenge. Some questions simply do not have a clear answer. Even after a consultation, people may still remain uncertain. They may need time to grieve or may continue to disagree. Our role is to bring greater clarity to the situation and create space for thoughtful conversation. We can help people understand the values at stake so those responsible for the decision can consider the path forward more carefully.

At its core, health care is people taking care of one another. Medical knowledge helps us understand what can be done. Clinical ethics helps us consider what should be done in light of what matters to the person receiving care. When the path forward is unclear, ethics and humanities help us keep that person in sight: who they are, how they have chosen to live, and what they need us to honor.

Eleanor Gilmore-Szott Headshot

Eleanor Gilmore-Szott, PhD, HEC-C

Eleanor Gilmore-Szott is an assistant professor of pediatrics and director of the Clinical Ethics Consultation Program at University of Utah Health’s Center for Health Ethics, Arts, and Humanities. Her research focuses on clinical ethics, medical decision-making, and health care AI. She received a PhD in applied ethics, bioethics, and philosophy of medicine at the University of Utah. 
 

DON'T MISS OUT. GOOD NOTES delivers to your inbox.